Proust’s financial madeleines

There are images that are forever associated with great crises, and every time we see them, we are reminded of their context, like Proust with his madeleine.  IMF chief Michel Camdessus watching over, as Indonesian President Suharto signed a financial assistance agreement, was the most vivid image of the 1997-1998 Asian Crisis; a generation of leaders across the emerging markets swore that never again would they be caught in such an embarrassing situation, which led to the massive foreign exchange reserves accumulation of the following decade.

The shared smirk between Chancellor Merkel and President Sarkozy, as they were asked about their faith in Prime Minister Berlusconi, has become the symbol of the current European crisis.  But what will it lead to?  PM Berlusconi has been replaced by PM Monti, and Italians are no fonder of public humiliations than Indonesians were back then.

Standard & Poor’s was criticized for having taken into account politics in its decision to downgrade the US.  They were just trying to look a few years ahead, and were right to introduce this qualitative factor.  If we want to look into the future of Europe, we should consider history and culture too.

Italy is the key to a successful European project.  It was a founding member of the European Coal and Steel Community in 1951, the first step toward the constitution of a European project, and of each of its subsequent iterations (the European Economic Community, the European Community and the European Union).  Its population and its economy have been of a size comparable to those of France and (West) Germany; leaving it out would have been like trying to build a stool with two legs.

The importance of Italy was and remains also rooted in history and culture.  Culturally, Italy is the gel that makes Europe click.  For all the outward demonstrations of affection, France and Germany are strong enough to head a balanced Europe, yet too different to make a harmonious one.  Imagine a symphonic orchestra with brass, percussion, woodwind but no string section.  It could play, but somehow it would not sound right and both players and the audience would soon tire of it. 

Finally, Italy is of strategic importance to a united Europe.  It represents its the Southern flank, bordering the Mediterranean basin, and offering the major entry point for people and goods from the former Yugoslavia, and beyond, through Turkey, from Central Asia.

So Italy, for all these reasons, is an essential part of Europe; should Italy fail, so would Europe.  And my judgment is that it won’t, and this for three reasons.

First, Italy’s current problem is one of economic and financial management, not one of solvency.  Unlike Greece, Italy can grow its economy to pay its debts.  Second, the rest of the euro zone has no choice but help Italy save itself, and themselves.  Third, Italy is on the edge of the precipice, and that is the only spot where people and countries will really accept to make changes; in this instance, this meant forcing out the prime minister, voting in a non-political cabinet led by the very able Mario Monti, and giving it two years to try and turn the country around.

Total success will be very difficult, but significant progress is likely.  In this case, France will find itself under tremendous pressure.  In the early 2000s, Chancellor G. Schröder substantially improved the German economic competitiveness through a broad mix of social, labor and tax reforms.    France did not, or could not, match this, and its labor productivity is generally estimated to have lagged Germany’s by at least 30% as a result.

If Mario Monti can convince his compatriots to make substantial reforms, France will be put in a very delicate position: not on the edge of the precipice to have to make big changes, but close enough to feel the intense pain.  Furthermore, with presidential elections coming up, it is out of the question to set up a “technocratic” government, and very unlikely to expect a coalition cabinet.  With profound political divisions and powerful trade unions accustomed to call strikes whenever they want to, the new president, Nicolas Sarkozy or François Hollande, may be in a position where the austerity measures that he can get approved in Congress are very unpopular yet insufficient to reverse mounting financial pressures.

Italy is not Greece, and I do expect that it will pull out, although I don’t expect this will be a linear process.  I do expect France to have a rough 2012 and possibly 2013.  Indeed, the image that will be most closely associated by this European crisis may not be the Franco-German “smirk”; it is yet to be seen and may be most Gallic in nature.